This update includes two notable additions to the previous post about the 1166% (yes, one thousand and some percent) overstatement of the Bush tally in one precinct of Ohio’s Franklin county:

1) The machine used in this precinct is only used in this county
2) It’s not a Diebold machine

#2 is more a curiosity than anything, and #1 makes it seem less likely that a similar problem happened throughout Ohio (that is, at least as long as one assumes this was a non-intentional error).

However, CNN’s turnout numbers for Franklin county show 512,599 votes counted. It’s hard with the available data to know how this one precinct’s error would extrapolate to the county if in fact the problem were county-wide, but with over half a million votes cast, it’s not hard to imagine a county-wide problem having a bottom-line impact on the outcome.

 

I’ve been accumulating anecdotes of voting issues for later tonight when I’ll have some time to read them more carefully, but this one is too striking to let sit:

Franklin County’s unofficial results had Bush receiving 4,258 votes to Democrat John Kerry (news – web sites)’s 260 votes in a precinct in Gahanna. Records show only 638 voters cast ballots in that precinct.

Bush actually received 365 votes in the precinct…

Hmm … a 136,000 vote Bush lead / (4258 – 638 = 3620) = 37 and change.

How many precincts were using this equipment? 37 machines with a similar flaw in similar magnitude changes everything, and once provisional ballots are considered the number probably doesn’t need to be anywhere near as large.

I swore I wasn’t going to let my tin-foil hat point in this direction, but this really needs some explanation.

A question I’ve been asking a lot lately is: Why don’t we have someone publicly accounting for why it’s OK that electronic voting machines aren’t auditable? More on that later …

 

I took Tuesday afternoon off of work to spend it doing whatever the Wisconsin Dems thought would be most useful. I ended up waving a Kerry Edwards sign on a street corner in a small community outside of Madison, which was actually substantially more fun than it probably sounds.

I never thought I’d see a nice-looking old grandma type give me the finger on the same afternoon I saw a middle-aged white guy give me (a not-quite-middle-aged white guy) the black power salute.

Grandma was far from alone in finding her middle finger to be the most eloquent response to “Kerry Edwards – For A Stronger America”. Other notable reacations on the not-so-positive side included:

* the old man who rolled down his window to say “you can’t possibly be that stupid” while turning

* lots of thumbs down, some with dramatic tension – as if they could _really_ get me if I thought the thumb was going up

* a pack of teenagers chanting “4 more years” from the school bus

* held noses, as if to limit the olfactory offense of my Kerry Edwards sign

* a young woman – maybe late teens or early twenties – who leaned halfway out of the passenger window of her car to deliver a two-handed bird flip while screaming “F*CK YOU” at a rather substantial volume

* the threat: “the police are on their way” (to do what, exactly? — they never came)

I woke up feeling optimistic and energized on Tuesday. From my point of view at the time, all of the above was more than offset by an outpouring of enthusiastic honking, cheering, thumbs up, and so forth. The spirit of a victory party was clear in the Kerry supporters I saw, while the Bush fans just seemed, well, angry and mean.

I’ll never know with any precision what the objective balance of opinion that drove by me on that corner was, but it was clearly a microcosm of sorts. I’ve thought about that microcosm while hearing the unity rhetoric that inevitably follows an electoral contest. GWB from yesterday’s speech:

…today I want to speak to every person who voted for my opponent: To make this nation stronger and better I will need your support, and I will work to earn it. I will do all I can do to deserve your trust. A new term is a new opportunity to reach out to the whole nation. We have one country, one Constitution and one future that binds us. And when we come together and work together, there is no limit to the greatness of America.

This, from the man whose first 4 years as “a uniter, not a divider” have let not only to what is widely regarded as the most divisive election in 36 years, but found government institutions in substantial conflict (CIA vs. DoD/White House, for example), driven a wedge through our allies (“Old Europe”, “Freedom Fries”, and repeated willful misrepresentation of the well-intentioned but regrettable Kerry phrase “global test”), and squandered historically unprecedented worldwide unity following the attacks of September 2001. Tell me, GW, are mandatory loyalty oaths a step towards how we “come together and work together”?

I have no personal ill will for Bush supporters by virtue of their support for Bush alone (as I learned on Tuesday, the converse is apparently not true). But puh-leeze, we don’t actually have a whole lot of common cause — none of the countless substantive reasons this was such a divisive election season have changed in the past 72 hours. Quite the contrary, apparently one day of playing nice-nice was enough for the administration:

“I earned capital in this campaign, political capital, and now I intend to spend it,” Bush told reporters. “It is my style.”

It’s going to be a long four years.

 

Nov 3, 2004

For months I’ve been refusing to let myself imagine today.

Jesusland

The shock, the despair, the unbe-freeking-lievableness of another 4 years of this administration was simply too much to bear thinking about while there was any hope of a different outcome. With some vodka and a very long day behind me, 1:30 am CDT today left enough of that hope (stretched as it became as the night grew long) for a few hours of more or less uninterrupted sleep. Of course, this morning rather quickly came to the current situation, in which the electoral triumph of the Bush administration is a fete accompli and that hope that has sustained and grown over the past 4 years faded.

So here we are. What now? For the 48% of US voters and the overwhelming majority of non-US observers who have seen the first GWB term as an extended binge of regrettable policy decisions, politically extremist pandering, shameless cronyism, and deceptive “leadership”, what is the next move? Where do we go with the energy that has been built up over the past few years behind the overwhelming but now deferred warrant for regime change?

I’ve heard a number of mutterings of “… gonna move to Canada …” from politically like-minded friends and co-workers today. Indeed, the “Dude, where’s my country” sentiment is persuasive — it’s an understatement to describe a 3+ million popular vote margin in favor of GWB as disorienting and unwelcoming. I’ve felt (and expressed) the urge to expatriation myself – it is comforting to imagine living someplace where the idea that people should be able to enjoy fruits of our collective progress like health care and shelter is accepted as just basic decency.

As disappointing and disheartening as Nov 2 2004 was, 49% of the country voted to send Bush back to Connecticut (er, Texas). Thousands of people volunteered weeks or months of their lives to join together in an effort to reclaim our country. Millions waited in long lines for hours yesterday to make their voices heard. I stood with over 80,000 people in Madison last week to hear Kerry — less than twice that number would have made the difference in Ohio, and consequently the electoral college.

This is too close a fight to run from.

Southcanadian

Jon’s 4th of July post this year was a welcome reminder for me — the US is a young country, and one based on a revolutionary idealism powered by individual conscience and conviction. I’m not ready to give up, which is what that would be for me (no offense to my good friends who recently relocated northwards intended — I hope that comfy guest bed is still available!). And even should today’s grim situation deteriorate and already thin hope continue to weaken over coming years or decades, I think there are worthwhile attempts yet to be made to (literally or figuratively) bring Canada here, as Jon so aptly put it while scooping what I had planned for the rest of this post … 😉

© 2021 layer8 Suffusion theme by Sayontan Sinha